Talk:List of oldest living men/@comment-1272640-20161222012759/@comment-26890527-20170803064757

Until I see documents for Mohyeddin and Veillard that support their ages, I will remain sceptical of both of their claims.

Look at other Iranian claims Djafar Behbahanian and Mansoor Pazargad. Are they pending yet?

Mohyeddin didn't emigrate to Canada until late in his life. It will probably be a challenge to find early-life documentation. Until that happens, I will remain a sceptic.

Same with Veillard. Not a single Haitian claim is pending yet (as far as I know). Anna Jean-Pierre, Leroisine Charles-Drouinaud, Vertulie Giordani, Dorrisile Dervis. They're all unvalidated. Until I see something like an original marriage certificate (because he claims to have been married for over 80 years) or other early-life documentation, I will continue to be sceptical.

So, like I said, until I see documents for both Mohyeddin and Veillard that support their claimed ages, their rightful place is in the questionable/limbo cases section.