Talk:Andrew Hatch/@comment-30591055-20161218214906/@comment-258494-20161218220234

You seriously misunderstand age validation (conversely, your lack of understanding proves the need for experts). "No proof" isn't proof. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence...we should not "assume" that a case is "true" because it's lacking proof, when the age claimed is greater than any validated male, ever.

Secondly, you seem to have an obsession/bias in favor of male claims to extreme longevity (Shigechiyo Izumi, Andrew Hatch, etc.). This type of obsession is not objective and doesn't lead to scientific findings of fact or statistical conclusions. Please, if you wish to talk about things like this, take it to the 110 Club (a discussion forum). These "talk" pages on the Gerontology Wiki are intended to assist with the article that it's associated with, not have a general POV fancruft type of discussion that you are trying to have.Ryoung122 (talk) 22:02, December 18, 2016 (UTC)