Thread:Arthur de Moraes Silva Barbosa/@comment-27547506-20191126231124

Hello Arthur, I noticed your recent articles about Latin American cases. I think that we don't need articles for every single known case. For example, you made an article for Maria Encarnacion Linares de Rivas of Venezuela, even though she was most certainly exaggerated and probably born in 1920s. She didn't even look plausible.

Secondly, I don't think it's a good idea to make an article for every case from social media, as I see you made the articles for Rosaura Cardozo and Victor Moran. I prefer making articles for plausible or researched (true) cases + we don't know anything about social media cases, only possible birthdate and name (and few informations if a relative shared it). Even some American cases that were exaggerated (or less plausible) don't have an article.

Cases like Esther Victoria Lecaro can be doubful too, but at least for them we have more informations and a better proof of reaching the age of 110+ (claimed age) than for the most of social media cases.

Let me give you one example, there's a Mexican man who was recently reported at the claimed age of 112, meaning he was born in 1906/1907, but earlier post from 2012 says he was 101 at that time. Social media cases should not have an article if they are not researched or if there's no more informations about them in past years. We don't know anything about Victor Moran, and yet he has an article now. 