Talk:Rosalia Hasenkampf/@comment-1272640-20160515221103/@comment-25898958-20160516100856

You can't be trusted not to violate OR rules.

The reason I am not in favour of citing original documents in cases like this is that 1. There are loads of cases where one particular document might support someone being older, when in reality it might just be due to things like ages being rounded up or errors being made, and 2. Individual documents often need to be viewed within context of research. To me, this is basically just an attempt to bypass the revalidation process.

Ok, so in a case like Lucy Hannah I don't mind putting a question mark by her year of birth. But when it's a question of someone being just a few days older/younger, I don't think it's necessary. Ollie231213 (talk) 10:08, May 16, 2016 (UTC)